The Cap'ns Slice

Amazing, authentic NY pizza for a great price! The best we've had in years. We drove an hour to Berlin, and would do it again just to come for the pizza.

This was my first time coming here but I've been wanting to try it for a while. The cashier and I believe it was the owner making pizzas, were both very nice and welcoming. They were also patient with me, and explained the pizzas because I was so indecisive, everything looked good! I ended up getting a slice of Zissou and the Joe. It was amazing! They definitely use high quality ingredients and I just love the combinations of flavors. It was hard to choose a favorite because they were both delicious. The crust was thin and crispy too. I will definitely be coming back to try more flavors. This is a wonderful small business to support.

If you’re anywhere near Berlin, Maryland, or even just passing through! Do yourself a favor and stop at Cap’ns Slice. This isn’t just pizza… it’s an experience.
From the moment you walk in, the atmosphere hits you. It’s fun, welcoming, laid-back, and full of personality — the kind of place where you instantly feel like a regular. The vibe alone makes you want to hang out, grab a slice, and stay awhile.
And let’s talk about Yancey, the owner. Absolute legend. Yancey has been in the game since the OG days, and you can taste that experience in every single bite. This isn’t basic pizza — this is iconic pizza. Perfect crust. Killer sauce. The kind of cheese pull that deserves its own slow-motion video. And the toppings? Creative, bold, and next-level. Yancey doesn’t just make pizza… he crafts it.
You can tell Yancey genuinely loves what he does. The energy, the fun-loving personality, the pride in every pie — it all shows. And now he’s even got his own beer with his face on it? Come on. That’s next-level cool.
Whether you’re a local or visiting from out of town, make the trip. Seriously. It’s well worth it for the atmosphere, the creativity, and some of the best pizza you’ll ever have and Yancey!
Cap’ns Slice isn’t just a pizza shop — it’s a whole vibe. 🍕🔥